Skip to content
SureReview

Airing a Offensive Word by a Ceremony Attendee with a Tic Disorder was a 'Serious Mistake', BBC Says.

Actors presenting an award on stage
The offensive term was shouted while actors were handing out an award.

The public service broadcaster has characterised the airing of a racist epithet by a guest with a neurological condition during the film awards ceremony as a "grave lapse", and stated its investigative body would expedite an investigation.

Advocate John Davidson, whose condition involves involuntary verbal tics, shouted the slur while performers were on the podium at the awards show.

A spokesman said: "The BBC has been examining what happened at Bafta on Sunday evening. This was a significant failure and the head has directed the Executive Complaints Unit (ECU) to undertake a fast-tracked probe and provide a full response to those who raised concerns."

The body rules on whether broadcast content has breached the corporation's content policies.

'Causes Concern'

Also on midweek, the chair of a select committee wrote to the soon-to-depart BBC director general to inquire how the situation occurred.

The Commons culture committee's chairwoman, said Sunday's transmission "raises questions about the extent to which lessons have been learned from previous scandals."

She referenced a set at Glastonbury last year, when the broadcaster aired derogatory statements and other derogatory comments made on the platform.

The committee questioned why the slur was not removed of Sunday's awards show, what systems are in operation to prevent such incidents, why lessons from the festival incident were not implemented at the awards, and what actions are being taken to prevent similar instances in the future.

An MP also wrote to the director general earlier in the week to ask for an "immediate clarification" for what happened.

A film poster or related imagery
The award-nominated film was based on Davidson's life story, growing up with the condition in 1980s Scotland.

The awards show in London was broadcast on a two-hour delay.

The racial slur was audible to television watchers, although a number would have struggled to clearly hear the term.

Davidson has argued the BBC should have "made a greater effort to prevent anything that I said" at the ceremony from being broadcast, and raised doubts about why he was positioned near a mic.

He stated to a publication: "There was a microphone just in front of me, and with retrospect I have to wonder about whether this was prudent, so close to where I was sitting, being aware I would utter involuntarily."

It is believed that the editing team preparing the ceremony for its time-shifted airing were working from a TV truck and simply did not hear the slur called out when the actors were on the podium.

The BBC has expressed regret on multiple occasions since the incident, and the ceremony remains inaccessible to watch on on-demand platforms after the broadcaster removed it.

On Tuesday, the senior executive told staff the BBC took "complete accountability" for what occurred, adding that another offensive term had been cut of the final edit.

In contrast, the one uttered when the actors were on the podium "was broadcast by mistake and we would not have knowingly allowed this to be televised," she stated.

In a statement on Monday, the academy said it recognised the "harm this has caused" and would "look into what transpired and say sorry to all."

In a letter to its membership on Tuesday, the organisation said it wanted to "reassure all our members that a thorough examination is under way."

Davidson, from the Scottish Borders, said he "had as much right" to be at Sunday's ceremony as any other guest. He is the subject and producer of a movie which tells the tale of his struggles with the syndrome and was nominated for multiple honours.

He said he uttered about 10 different offensive words during the show as a result of his tics, but the media coverage has created a perception the racial epithet was the only one.

After shouting the slur, Davidson said he decided to leave the main hall "so as not to cause any more offence", noting that Bafta provided a private room with a monitor to watch the remainder of the proceedings.

It was stated that he has reached out to studio representatives in order to apologise directly to the individuals involved, who also spoke about being subjected to racial slurs.

'Profoundly Painful'

Davidson also stated: "I want to be really clear that the intent behind them [the tics] is non-existent. What you're hearing is a by-product - not my beliefs, not my thought, not my conviction."

He said he felt a "feeling of humiliation and discomfort" after shouting the offensive term.

"The utterances me shouting is truly the final thing in the world I believe; it is the reverse of what I believe," he explained.

"The most derogatory slur that I uttered involuntarily at the ceremony, for example, is a term I would absolutely refrain from using and would completely condemn if I did not have this condition."

The leader of a support organisation also released a comment urging hostility against Davidson to end.

"The hurt experienced and the effect experienced by the black community is genuine and profoundly legitimate - terms like these carry past and psychological weight that cannot be dismissed," she stated.

"At the same time, the abuse, attacks, and animosity directed toward John and the wider community in the afterwards have been profoundly painful. Nobody wins when groups are set against one another."

The writer

Casey Hoffman

A tech journalist and product reviewer with over 8 years of experience testing gadgets and appliances, specializing in consumer electronics and smart home devices.

SureReview

Type to search articles.